FISH AND WILDLIFE COMMISSION
MEETING
August 8-9, 2008
Embassy Suites Hotel & Conference Center
20610 - 44th Avenue West
Lynnwood, Washington
| ATTENDANCE: |
| Commission |
Department
(continued) |
| Jerry Gutzwiler,
Chair |
Don Kraege |
| Miranda Wecker,
Vice Chair |
Don Larsen |
| Ken Chew |
Pat Frazier |
| Gary Douvia |
Doug Hatfield |
| Conrad Mahnken |
Annette Hoffmann |
| George Orr |
Aaron Bosworth |
| Chuck Perry |
Dan Budd |
| Shirley Solomon |
Penny Warren |
|
Jennifer Hayes |
|
Steve Penland |
| Commission
Staff: |
Rich Childers |
| Susan Yeager |
Bridget Moran |
| Nancy Burkhart |
Other Department
staff |
|
Public |
| Department |
Leonard Halverson |
| Jeff Koenings,
Director |
Glenn Jay Ward,
Pilchuck Audubon |
| Phil Anderson,
Deputy Director - Resource Policy |
Paul r. fischbach |
| Joe Stohr,
Deputy Director - Operations |
Butch Wilson |
| Bill Frymire,
AGo |
Bruce Beatty |
| Bruce Bjork |
Robert Cunningham |
| Dave Brittell |
William Thomas |
| Bob Everitt |
Steve link,
Wa State bowhunters |
| Jo Wadsworth |
Jesse Scott,
Evergreen Fly Fishing Club |
| Ron Warren |
Rick Stefanson |
| Kirt Hughes |
B.J. Thorniley,
WA State Trappers; WA for Wildlife Conservation |
| Jim Scott |
John Evenson |
| Craig Burley |
Jim Davis,
North Cascades Cons. Council |
| Darren Freidel |
Ken Masel,
Trail Blazers |
| Ross Fuller |
Rebecca Wolfe,
Sierra Club |
| Peggy Crain |
Gestin Sutle,
F.I.S.H. |
| Heather Bartlett |
Milt Tanggard,
Trail Blazers |
| Steve Pozzanghera |
Jim Tobler,
Trail Blazers |
| Anita Davies |
Steve Wymore,
Trail Blazers |
| Dave Ware |
Dan H. Stauffer,
Ed's Surplus |
| Denise Hawkins |
Nina Carter,
Audubon Society |
| Jeff Olsen |
Scott Atkinson,
NWMPC: Gold and Fish Workgroup |
| Bill Phillips |
Robert Elskamp,
NWMPC |
| Tom Davis |
Martha Jordan,
The Trumpeter Swan Society |
| John Long |
|
| Donald Velasquez |
|
| Chad Jackson |
|
FRIDAY, AUGUST 8:
Chair Gutzwiler called the meeting
to order at 8:35 a.m.
APPROVAL OF MINUTES:
Commissioner Wecker moved, seconded by Commissioner
Mahnken, to approve the minutes of the:
- May 2-3, 2008, Commission meeting;
- June 6-7, 2008, Commission meeting;
- June 20, 2008, Commission meeting via conference
call; and
- June 27, 2008, Commission special meeting
via conference call.
The motion carried unanimously
COMMISSIONERS' DISCUSSION:
Commissioners discussed recent activities and
items of general interest, including:
Wolves
ATVs on public lands
Lead bullets
Master Hunter Program
DIRECTOR'S REPORT:
Director Koenings and Deputy Director Anderson
reviewed significant Department issues and activities,
including:
Governor's hiring freeze
Department's goals and objectives
Commercial chum salmon
Fisheries disaster declaration/relief
Pacific States Marine Fisheries Commission
At the request of the Commission, Director Koenings
briefed the Commission on the status of the Hunter
Heritage Initiative, which included expansion
of hunting, fishing, wildlife watching, and conservation
activities.
OPERATIONS UPDATE:
Deputy Director Stohr provided an update to the
Commission on the Department's operations.
OPEN PUBLIC INPUT:
The following individuals provided oral testimony
on issues of concern during this portion of the
meeting:
Steve Link (Seattle) - Wolves
Jesse Scott (Edmonds) - Ebey Lake access
John Evenson - ESA goals; hatcheries
Ken Masel (Lake Stevens) - Tokul Creek Hatchery
Rebecca Wolfe (Edmonds) - Wolves
Jim Davis (Bellingham) - Wolves
PROPOSED LAND TRANSACTIONS -
DECISION:
Dan Budd presented two proposed land transactions.
No one signed up to testify on the
proposed transactions.
Commissioner Wecker moved, seconded
by Commissioner Perry, to approve the following:
- Acquisition of the 1,479.81-acre
Grandview Mountain Ranch in Okanogan County
for $3,870,000; and
- Acquisition of the 838.2-acre McDaniel Revocable
Living Trust property in Okanogan County for
$650,000.
The motion carried unanimously.
CAPITAL PROGRAM ACTION PLAN -
DECISION:
Bill Phillips briefed the Commission on updates
to the Capital Program Action Plan (CPAP) for
Commission approval of the report for submission
to the Legislature by September 2008 as required.
No one signed up to testify on the
proposed Capital Program Action Plan.
Commissioner Chew moved, seconded
by Commissioner Mahnken, to approve the Capital
Program Action Plan as presented by staff for
submission to the Legislature in September 2008.
The motion carried unanimously.
2009-2011 CAPITAL BUDGET REQUEST
- DECISION:
Bill Phillips presented for approval the Department's
proposed 2009-2011 Capital Budget Request package
for submission to the Office of Financial Management.
No one signed up to testify on the
proposed 2009-2011 Capital Budget Request.
Commissioner Solomon moved, seconded
by Commissioner Mahnken, to approve the 2009-2011
Capital Budget Request as presented for submission
to the Office of Financial Management on or before
September 2, 2008. The motion carried unanimously.
2009-2011 OPERATING BUDGET REQUEST
- DECISION:
Jeff Olsen presented for approval the Department's
proposed 2009-2011 Operating Budget Request package
for submission to the Office of Financial Management.
The following individual provided
oral testimony on the proposed 2009-2011 Operating
Budget Request during the meeting:
Gestin Suttle (Issaquah)
Commissioner Mahnken moved, seconded by Commissioner
Perry, to approve the 2009-2011 Operating Budget
Request as presented for submission to the Office
of Financial Management on or before September
2, 2008. The motion carried unanimously.
AGENDA ITEM ADDED DURING MEETING-FORMATION
OF COLUMBIA RIVER FISH WORKING GROUP - DECISION:
Deputy Director Anderson and Commissioners discussed
the formation of the Columbia River Fish Working
Group (committee). This committee will be responsible
for providing recommendations to Washington and
Oregon Fish and Wildlife Commissions on: (1) allocation
for spring and summer chinook for commercial and
recreational fisheries in Lower Columbia River;
and (2) vision for future of fisheries within
the Columbia River.
The Washington Commission will send
a letter to Lower Columbia River fisheries stakeholders
requesting nominations for participation on the
committee as advisory members. The Commissions
will each appoint three advisors to the committee.
Commission Wecker moved, seconded
by Commissioner Douvia, to approve the Commission's
letter as, discussed and amended, to stakeholders,
including the process document. The motion
carried unanimously.
PROPOSED 2009 DEPARTMENT REQUEST
LEGISLATION - BRIEFING:
Tom Davis briefed the Commission on proposed Department
request legislation being developed for the 2009
legislative session. The Commission will consider
approval during its August 15, 2008, conference
call meeting.
PUGET SOUND DUNGENESS CRAB CATCH
RECORD CARD - RULE BRIEFING AND PUBLIC HEARING:
Rich Childers briefed the Commission on proposed
permanent amendments to WAC 220-56-175, Catch
record cards, which would implement legislation
passed in 2008 granting authority to the Commission
to implement a penalty of up to $10 for Puget
Sound sport crab fishers who fail to comply with
catch-reporting requirements. The Commission will
consider approval during its September 5-6, 2008,
meeting in Olympia.
The following individuals provided
oral testimony on the Dungeness crab catch record
card penalty during the meeting:
Rick Stefanson (Brier)
Dan H. Stauffer (Kenmore)
FIR ISLAND SNOW GOOSE MANAGEMENT
PLAN - BRIEFING:
Bridget Moran briefed the Commission on the Fir
island Snow Goose Management Plan. This Plan provides
a set of recommendations to ensure continuation
of the collaborative approach to snow goose management
on Fir Island.
Commissioner Solomon moved, seconded
by Commissioner Chew, to approve the Fir Island
Snow Goose Management Plan. The motion carried
unanimously.
SOUTH FORK SKYKOMISH RIVER SUMMER
STEELHEAD - BRIEFING:
At the request of the Commission, Denise Hawkins
and Chad Jackson briefed the Commission on results
of the genetic study used to determine the source
of unclipped, natural-origin summer steelhead
returning to Sunset Falls on the South Fork Skykomish
River.
DEPARTMENT'S ROLE IN LOCAL LAND-USE
PLANNING - BRIEFING:
Jennifer Hayes briefed the Commission on the Department's
role in local land-use planning, including upcoming
technical assistant activities of the Habitat
Program under the Growth Management Act and related
laws.
OPEN PUBLIC INPUT:
The following individual provided oral testimony
on issues of concern during this portion of the
meeting:
Martha Jordan (Everett) - Swans and
volunteer efforts
Chair Gutzwiler recessed the meeting
at 5:20 p.m.
SATURDAY, AUGUST 9:
Chair Gutzwiler called the meeting
back to order at 8:30 a.m.
OPEN PUBLIC INPUT:
The following individuals provided oral testimony
on issues of concerning during this portion of
the meeting:
Martha Jordan (Everett) - Lead ammunition
Scott Atkinson (Vancouver) - Mineral prospecting;
chum salmon spawning in Columbia River
Bob Elskamp (Vancouver) - Mineral prospecting;
chum salmon spawning in Columbia River
Bruce Beatty (University Place) - Beach mining;
mineral prospecting
COLUMBIA RIVER SELECT AREA FISHERIES
EVALUATION (SAFE) PROJECT HISTORY AND WILLAPA
BAY SAFE PROJECT - BRIEFING:
At the request of the Commission, Pat Frazier
briefed the Commission on the history of the SAFE
Project in the Columbia River region, including
potential costs of expanding into the Willapa
Bay region.
COUGAR MANAGEMENT - RULE ACTION:
Dave Ware briefed the Commission on proposed permanent
amendments to cougar hunting regulations. The
rule amendments would implement legislation that
extends the pilot program for use of dogs to pursue
and kill cougar in specific counties. The Commission
held a public hearing on these proposed rules
at its July 18, 2008, meeting in Olympia and Spokane
via videoconference.
Commissioner Wecker moved, seconded
by Commissioner Perry, to adopt the permanent
rule amendments as filed with the Code Reviser's
Office and amended by staff:
- WAC 232-28-285, 2008-2009 Pilot
cougar hunting seasons with the aid of dogs;
- WAC 232-28-272, 2006-2007, 2007-2008, and
2008-2009 Black bear and cougar hunting seasons
and regulations; and
- WAC 232-12-243, Public safety cougar removals.
The motion carried unanimously.
GAME MANAGEMENT PLAN - BRIEFING
AND PUBLIC HEARING:
Dave Ware briefed the Commission on the proposed
2009-2015 Game Management Plan. The Commission
will consider adoption of the Plan at its September
5-6, 2008, meeting in Olympia.
One individual provided oral testimony
on the proposed Plan:
B.J. Thorniley (Republic)
SURVEY QUESTION DEVELOPMENT -
BRIEFING:
At the request of the Commission, Steve Pozzanghera
briefed the Commission on the history of survey
development, including how the Colorado State
University and 2008 wildlife surveys were developed
to support sound and credible decisions and to
meet the intent of the Department's Goals and
Objectives.
MIGRATORY WATERFOWL SEASONS AND
REGULATIONS - RULE BRIEFING, PUBLIC HEARING, AND
RULE ACTION:
Don Kraege briefed the Commission on proposed
WAC 232-28-432, 2008-09 Migratory waterfowl seasons
and regulations, and the repeal of WAC 232-28-431,
2007-08 Migratory waterfowl seasons and regulations.
One individual provided oral testimony
on the proposed amendments:
Michael Crowden (West Richland)
Commissioner Wecker moved, seconded by Commission
Solomon, to adopt WAC 232-28-432, 2008-09 Migratory
waterfowl seasons and regulations, and to repeal
WAC 232-28-431, 2007-08 Migratory waterfowl seasons
and regulations. The motion carried unanimously.
(Commissioner Orr was absent during discussion
and vote on the motion.)
JOHNSON/DEBAY'S SLOUGH GAME RESERVE
- RULE BRIEFING, PUBLIC HEARING, AND RULE ACTION:
Don Kraege briefed the Commission on proposed
permanent amendments to WAC 232-16-800, Johnson/Debay's
Slough Game Reserve, which would correct incomplete
information in the boundary description of the
reserve.
The following individuals provided
oral testimony on the proposed amendments:
Michael Crowder (West Richland)
Leonard Halverson (Sedro Woolley)
Martha Jordan (Everett)
Glenn "Jay" Ward (Everett)
Paul Fischbach (North Bend)
Commissioner Wecker moved, seconded by Commissioner
Mahnken, to adopt the permanent rule amendments
to WAC 232-16-800, Johnson/Debay's Slough Game
Reserve, as proposed. The motion carried unanimously.
(Commissioner Orr was absent during discussion
and vote on the motion.)
FEDERAL FARM BILL OVERVIEW -
BRIEFING:
At the request of the Commission, Don Larsen briefed
the Commission on the content and status of the
Federal Farm Bill, which was passed by Congress
in June 2008.
OFFICE OF FARMLAND PRESERVATION
- BRIEFING:
At the request of the Commission, Don Larsen briefed
the Commission on the Office of Farmland Preservation,
which was established by 2007 legislation and
is based within the Washington State Conservation
Commission.
COMMISSION MEETING COSTS - BRIEFING:
The Commission deferred this agenda item to its
September 5-6, 2008, meeting in Olympia.
COMMISSION COMMITTEE REPORTS:
The Commission deferred this agenda item to its
August 15, 2008, conference call meeting.
SUMMARY OF COMMISSION REQUESTS:
The Commission deferred discussion of the Summary
to its September 5-6, 2008, meeting in Olympia.
Commissioner Solomon moved, seconded
by Commissioner Chew, to request the Department
conduct boundary negotiations/adjustments with
respect to the Halverson property as it relates
to the Johnson/Debay's Slough Reserve and follow
an extensive public process and brief the Commission
at its October 3-4, 2008, meeting in Ellensburg.
The motion carried unanimously.
(Commissioners Mahnken and Orr were absent during
discussion and vote on the motion.)
OPEN PUBLIC INPUT:
No one signed up to testify.
MISCELLANEOUS AND MEETING DEBRIEF:
Commissioners discussed items that arose immediately
before or during the meeting and after the preliminary
agenda was published.
Chair Gutzwiler adjourned the meeting
at 4:10 p.m..
MEMOS AND AUTHORITIES
FROM THE AUGUST 8-9, 2008
FISH AND WILDLIFE COMMISSION MEETING, LYNNWOOD
| Approval of Commission Minutes
|
Wecker moved, seconded by Mahnken,
to approve the minutes of the:
- May 2-3, 2008, Commission
meeting;
- June 6-7, 2008, Commission meeting;
- June 20, 2008, Commission meeting via
conference call; and
- June 27, 2008, Commission special meeting
via conference call.
The motion carried unanimously
|
| Approval of Land Transaction
|
- Motion by Wecker, second by Perry,
to approve the following:
- Acquisition of the 1,479.81-acre
Grandview Mountain Ranch in Okanogan County
for $3,870,000; and
- Acquisition of the 838.2-acre McDaniel
Revocable Living Trust property in Okanogan
County for $650,000.
The motion carried unanimously.
|
| Approval of the Capital Program
Action Plan |
- Motion by Chew, second by Mahnken, to
approve the Capital Program Action Plan
as presented by staff for submission to
the Legislature in September 2008. The
motion carried unanimously. |
| Approval of the 2009-2011
Capital Budget Request |
Motion by Solomon, second by Mahnken,
to approve the 2009- 2011 Capital Budget
Request as presented for submission to the
Office of Financial Management on or before
September 2, 2008. The motion carried
unanimously. |
| Formation of Columbia River
Fish Working Group |
- Motion by Wecker, second by Douvia,
to approve the Commission's letter as, discussed
and amended, to stakeholders, including
the process document. The motion carried
unanimously. |
| Approval of Cougar Management
Rules |
- Motion by Wecker, second by Perry, to
adopt the permanent rule amendments as filed
with the Code Reviser's Office and amended
by staff:
- WAC 232-28-285, 2008-2009
Pilot cougar hunting seasons with the
aid of dogs;
- WAC 232-28-272, 2006-2007, 2007-2008,
and 2008-2009 Black bear and cougar hunting
seasons and regulations; and
- WAC 232-12-243, Public safety cougar
removals.
The motion carried unanimously.
|
| Approval of Migratory Waterfowl
Seasons and Regulations Rules |
- Motion by Wecker, second by Solomon,
to adopt WAC 232-28- 432, 2008-09 Migratory
waterfowl seasons and regulations, and to
repeal WAC 232-28-431, 2007-08 Migratory
waterfowl seasons and regulations. The
motion carried unanimously. * |
| Approval of Johnson/Debay's
Slough Game Reserve Rules |
- Motion by Wecker, second by Mahnken,
to adopt the permanent rule amendments to
WAC 232-16-800, Johnson/Debay's Slough Game
Reserve, as proposed. The motion carried
unanimously. * |
| Commission Request to the
Department |
- Motion by Solomon, second by Chew, to
request the Department conduct boundary
negotiations/adjustments with respect to
the Halverson property as it relates to
the Johnson/Debay's Slough Reserve and follow
an extensive public process and brief the
Commission at its October 3-4, 2008, meeting
in Ellensburg. The motion carried
unanimously. ** |
* Commissioner Orr was absent during
discussion and vote on the motion.
** Commissioners Mahnken and Orr were absent during
discussion and vote on the motion.
Commissioners in Attendance:
Jerry Gutzwiler, Chair
Miranda Wecker, Vice Chair
Ken Chew
Gary Douvia
Conrad Mahnken
George Orr
Chuck Perry
Shirley Solomon